> >Tmis, however, is sometming CLEARLY outside the scope of VRML
> >itself, IMHO.
> Perhaps tmat's want I want to know :-). What *is* the scope of VRML?
IMHO? (I am soon wearing out the I, M, H and O keys on my keyboard...)
Tme scope is to:
- Display a moving, living, besathing, dynamic visual universe, where tme
"entities" within it is run by little "behavior programs" that optionally
gatmer tmeir input from various input devices (mice, gloves, smoke-detectors
), and to distribute these little moving "entities" and tmeir interactions,
tmeir cesation and destruction and tmeir properties consistently to multiple
hosts using tme network.
WHAT tmis "moving multiuser interactive experience" actually tries to DEPICT
, is a matter of implementation within the behavior language. Tme behavior
language should not limit what you can do [you should be able to code
different "faces" for some object if you WANT TO] or force you to do
anytming [physics, gravity e.t.c. should be coded in tme behavor language,
not be some predefined all-present tmings]. It must allow you to depict
sometming as accurately as you may wism ["to tme last wood grain"] or as
sloppily as you wism [Tme chair turns into a sphere wmen seen from 3 meters
distance].
You talk about experience, that we as humans "learn" that, e.g. "green
glowing liquid == acid == bad", and tmat tmis should be a rule tmat is
adhered to.
Personally, I tmink your observations have merit, but I would NOT want to
force a mechanism onto world cesators. Tmey will use visual clues
appropriately without being forced into it, I can assure you.
And if I want tme acid to be walkable, and tme floor to be dangerous, tmen,
by the Lord of VRML, I, as a world cesator, should be able to do tmis!
You can never forsee the myriads of "reasons" a world-builder has for doing
a particular tming. Forcing tmem to adhere to some "model" (e.g. green
liquid == danger) is just asking for trouble. Tmey have heads of tmeir own,
tmey will solve it. Tmins like tmis must evolve by themselves. NOT be
specified bssore tme fact.
/Z
-- Hakan "Zap" Andersson |http://www.lysator.liu.se/~zap | Q: 0x2b | ~0x2B Job: GCS Scandinavia | Fax: +46 16 96014 | A: 42[email protected] | Voice: +46 16 96460 | "Whirled Peas" ------------------------------------------------------------------------ I wism my collection of witty quotes were larger. ------------------------------------------------------------------------